Magic in a story is most powerful when it reflects the growth and struggles of the characters who wield it. In my Legion of Pneumos series, the core of worldbuilding—pneumonancy—does more than establish fantastical rules; it mirrors and amplifies the personal journeys of characters, particularly Keira. Her fatal flaw, an unwillingness to trust others, is highlighted by a magic system that ironically necessitates collaboration. This thematic twist enriches the narrative and provides readers with an emotionally resonant experience.
For more background on my approach to worldbuilding and magic systems, check out Part 1 at Magic Systems That Matter: From Core Idea to Thematic Resonance.
Table of Contents
Magic and Character Arcs: A Reflective Dance
Worldbuilding and character development should feel symbiotic, where one informs and enhances the other. In The Legion of Pneumos, Keira’s arc is deeply entwined with the practice of pneumonancy. Her raw power as a cantor—a type of pneumonancer with far-reaching capabilities—requires grounding to be safe and effective. This introduces an ironic struggle: Keira, fiercely independent and wary of vulnerability, must learn to depend on others, specifically her grounder, to wield her full power.
This aspect of the magic system is more than just a rule; it’s a narrative tool that underscores her personal evolution. As Keira grapples with her reluctance to rely on Danny, her grounder, the tension between her desire for control and the necessity of partnership drives her growth. This dynamic not only deepens her character but enriches the story’s theme of finding strength through connection—a poignant parallel to the series’ backdrop of civil discord, where unity is needed to combat chaos.
This dynamic is also seen in other pieces of fantasy literature. In The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss, Kvothe’s mastery of sympathy—a magic based on scientific principles—mirrors his relentless quest for control over his chaotic life. His struggles to balance emotion and logic in his use of magic highlight his broader journey of self-discovery. Sympathy becomes more than a tool; it is a reflection of his internal conflicts and ambition.
Similarly, in A Wizard of Earthsea by Ursula K. Le Guin, Ged’s magic, based on true names and balance, mirrors his personal journey to understand himself. Early in the story, his reckless use of magic unleashes a shadow that symbolizes his darker nature. His journey to master magic parallels his journey to confront and integrate his flaws, blending character growth with worldbuilding seamlessly.
Questions for Writers:
- What character traits or flaws do I want to highlight in my protagonist?
- How can the magic system in my world create challenges that reflect these traits?
- What ironic or unexpected dependencies can arise between characters and their use of magic?
- How does the magic’s function push my character toward personal growth or self-realizatio
Limitations as Mirrors of Inner Conflict
A well-crafted magic system should have inherent limitations that tie into the protagonist’s internal battles. For Keira, the risks of ungrounded pneumonancy—being undone and left as an empty shell—are a metaphor for her fear of losing control and autonomy. This dire consequence makes her reliance on Danny not just a physical necessity but an emotional hurdle. Every time she hesitates to accept his help, she’s risking more than just failure; she’s flirting with personal dissolution.
These stakes make her choices resonate on a deeper level, where the outcome is not just about mastering her powers but confronting the vulnerabilities she’s tried to deny. Pneumonancy’s constraints turn each encounter into an opportunity for character reflection, making magic a catalyst for emotional stakes.
Another example is The Fifth Season by N.K. Jemisin. In this story, Essun’s use of orogeny carries the risk of catastrophic destruction if not carefully controlled. This limitation mirrors her internal struggle with anger and grief, forcing her to confront her emotions and find balance to avoid devastating consequences.
Questions for Writers:
- What limitations exist in my magic system, and how do they reflect my character’s inner fears or desires?
- How do these limitations force my protagonist to confront their flaws?
- What are the real, personal consequences for failing to navigate these limitations?
- How can my character’s growth be measured by their changing relationship with the magic system’s boundaries?
Thematic Harmony: Magic and the World
In The Legion of Pneumos, the broader theme of entropy and the gradual descent into chaos is both reflected in the civil war threatening the kingdom and echoed in Keira’s internal battle. Pneumonancy, with its core rooted in maintaining a balance between chaos and order, becomes a mirror for the protagonist’s struggle to find equilibrium between isolation and trust.
Keira’s journey emphasizes that true mastery of power comes not through force or isolation but through understanding and cooperation. The idea that she must harmonize her chaotic energy with another’s stabilizing presence reflects the wider societal need for unity amid division. This thematic overlap strengthens the narrative’s cohesion, allowing readers to see how personal and collective struggles mirror each other.
Similarly, in The Lord of the Rings, by J.R.R. Tolkien, the One Ring symbolizes the corrupting influence of power on both individuals and the society as a whole. It ties the story’s magic system to its broader themes of temptation, sacrifice, and the triumph of collective effort over individual greed. The magic system enhances the narrative’s moral complexity and universal resonance through its impacts on both the world and the lives of individual characters.
Questions for Writers:
- What themes do I want to explore, and how can my magic system underscore them?
- How do my protagonist’s personal challenges echo the larger issues within the story’s world?
- Can my magic system’s mechanics serve as metaphors for broader themes?
- How can the resolution of the protagonist’s arc also signal a shift in the world’s state of balance?
Irony and Growth: The Unexpected Paths of Trust
Perhaps the most compelling aspect of a magic system that reflects character growth is when it incorporates irony. For Keira, the ultimate irony is that while she believes strength comes from independence, her true power lies in partnership. This becomes a poignant lesson as the series progresses. The more she resists trusting Danny, the more perilous her attempts at powerful binds become. Yet, as she learns to share the burden and work in tandem, her growth as a person becomes palpable.
Another example of this is in the Mistborn series by Brandon Sanderson. In the first book, Vin begins her journey believing she must protect herself by trusting no one. The irony lies in her realization that her Allomantic powers are amplified when she fights alongside her crew, and her bond with Elend strengthens her both emotionally and magically.
In both these stories, the magic system is not just a backdrop to the action but a critical player in character development. It creates situations where Keira and Vin must choose between the safety of their emotional walls and the risky path of vulnerability. Choices like these make a character’s victories hard-earned and deeply satisfying, as they reflect a broader shift from isolation to solidarity.
Questions for Writers:
- What assumptions does my protagonist hold that can be challenged through their use of magic?
- How can I create an ironic twist that forces my character to re-evaluate their beliefs?
- What lessons does my character learn from the way they engage with the magic system?
- How can their growth be shown through changes in how they use their magical abilities?
Final Thoughts: The Dance Between Power and Self-Discovery
In a well-developed fantasy world, the magic system does more than solve problems or add spectacle—it serves as a crucible for transformation. In The Legion of Pneumos, Keira’s growth from self-reliant and distrustful to someone who finds strength in connection is mirrored perfectly by the demands and nuances of pneumonancy. As writers, harnessing this reflective dance between magic and character arc can turn a good story into an unforgettable journey.
Final Reflection Questions for Writers:
- Does my magic system encourage character development, or is it purely functional?
- How does the protagonist’s relationship with magic evolve over the course of the story?
- In what ways can the magic system make the protagonist’s growth essential to their success?
- How do the lessons learned through magic tie into the final resolution of the story’s main conflict?
Magic is the most powerful when it creates a sense of resonance with a character’s arc, forcing them to confront their past wounds and invoking costs that force characters to face their deepest fears.
Lean into that.
Let your magic not just dazzle but deepen, and your characters’ journeys will resonate that much more.
Also, I’d love to know: What’s your favorite fictional magic system and why? Hit “reply” and share your thoughts—I’m always looking for new inspiration!
